“Natural” Isn’t Always Harmless — The Truth Behind the Label

ARTICLES

Dr. Islam Sharqeyeh

11/27/20252 min read

a person holding a small bottle of medicine
a person holding a small bottle of medicine

When a product is labeled “natural,” many people automatically think: safe, healthy, gentle. After all — it comes from plants, right? But that assumption can be dangerously misleading. In reality, “natural” doesn’t guarantee safety or effectiveness — and sometimes the opposite.

⚠️ Why “Natural” Can Be Risky
  • The label “natural” isn’t regulated. A “natural supplement” might be highly processed, contain doses far above safe limits, or include undisclosed substances.

  • Many products don’t undergo rigorous testing. Unlike prescription drugs, most herbal supplements and natural remedies are not required to be proven safe or effective before being sold.

  • Safety varies wildly from product to product. Some herbs are potent enough to interfere with medications, or even cause serious harm. For example, certain herbal medicines have been linked to liver toxicity, allergic reactions, or negative interactions with regular drugs.

  • Contamination is common. Studies show certain natural products may contain heavy metals, pesticides, or be adulterated with pharmaceuticals — because manufacturing and quality controls are often minimal.

📚 What the Evidence Shows
  • A review of herbal‑medicine safety concluded that while many herbal products are widely used, the lack of high‑quality, well‑controlled clinical trials makes it difficult to reliably assess their safety or efficacy.

  • Research documented that some herbal supplements can cause serious adverse effects — from organ damage to unexpected interactions with conventional medications.

  • Historical examples highlight the danger of assuming “natural = safe”: a plant may contain potent compounds — some used in modern drugs — but in its raw or unregulated form, dosage and purity are unpredictable.

🧠 What Consumers Should Do Instead
  1. Don’t trust marketing alone. Avoid buying products just because they’re labelled “natural,” “herbal,” or “organic.”

  2. Seek evidence. Look for peer-reviewed studies, regulated clinical trials, or official warnings before using herbal remedies or supplements.

  3. Check quality & purity. Try to use products that have undergone independent testing for contaminants or correct dosage — many don’t.

  4. Consult trusted healthcare professionals. Especially important if you take other medications or have chronic conditions.

  5. Focus on lifestyle fundamentals first. Balanced diet, regular activity, adequate sleep — no supplement can replace good habits.

📚 Recent Evidence & Cases: When “Natural” Went Wrong
• Liver & organ damage linked to herbal supplements
  • A 2023 review concluded that herbal and dietary supplements — despite being popular — are a frequent cause of liver injury, with tens of thousands of adverse events reported each year.

  • Some common herbal products often considered “harmless,” such as extracts of turmeric, green tea, ashwagandha, garcinia cambogia, red yeast rice, and black cohosh, have been associated with hepatotoxicity (liver toxicity).

  • In 2025, media outlets reported a serious case — a woman needed hospitalisation and came “one step before liver failure” after taking high‑dose turmeric supplements. Her liver enzyme levels reportedly rose massively.

• Poor regulation — contamination and mislabeling are common
  • A 2024 scientific study in Saudi Arabia found that many herbal‑medicine products were contaminated: some contained heavy metals or microbial contamination.

  • Experts warn that, unlike prescription drugs, many herbal and dietary supplements are not strictly tested or regulated. Some products may include contaminants, adulterants, or inconsistent potency.

• Risky interactions and unpredictable toxicity
  • Use of herbal supplements alongside prescription medications can lead to serious interactions or toxicity. A study recently highlighted that herbal and dietary supplements may alter how medications work, or amplify their side‑effects.

  • Kidneys — as well as liver — are particularly vulnerable to harm from certain herbal products. Some herbs have been linked to acute kidney injury or chronic harm because of toxic compounds, improper preparation, or contamination.